top of page

How to Pass a Nonprofit Audit: A Simple Guide

Sep 22
3 min read

Updated: Nov 15

Most of the nonprofits I have worked with over the last three, or four years failed their audit. Almost every single one was missing the same few things.

If you want to pass your next audit, here is exactly what auditors look for.


Keep Your Paper Trail

Auditors want proof. They will ask for things like:

  1. Receipts for every purchase

  2. Bills and invoices

  3. Backup for every journal entry you make

  4. Timestamps showing when work was done or approved

  5. Board meeting minutes

If you cannot show proof, the auditor cannot check your work. That is when problems start. Keep all of this in one place so you can find it fast when it is time for your audit.


Write Down How Your Business Runs

You also need a document that explains how your organization handles money and makes decisions. This should cover things like who approves expenses, who signs checks, and who is allowed to do what. Auditors want to see this in writing, not just hear you explain it.


The Biggest Problem: Weak Internal Controls

Out of everything I just listed, weak internal controls cause the most audit failures. This happens when one person does too much.

Here is an example of what goes wrong. One person counts the money. That same person takes the money to the bank. That same person also enters the money into the accounting system. When one person controls every step, there is no way to check their work. This is a big red flag for auditors, even if nothing bad ever happened.


The fix is simple. Split these jobs up between different people. This is called segregation of duties. It does not have to be complicated. Even a small team can do this. For example, your office manager could count the money while someone else makes the deposit and a third person enters it into the books. As long as more than one person is involved, you are in much better shape.


Know Your Restricted Funds

Auditors pay close attention to money that donors or funders gave for a set purpose. This is called restricted money. You must be able to show how much came in, how much was spent, and how much is left for each one.

If a grant paid for a program, the auditor will look for proof that the money went to that program. Keep a simple list of each restricted gift or grant. Write down the amount, the purpose, the start date, and the end date. Update it each month.

Review Your Own Reports First

Do not wait for the auditor to find mistakes. Look at your own reports each month. Check that your bank balance in your books matches your bank statement. Look for large or odd entries that you cannot explain. Make sure every expense is in the right account and the right fund.

When you find a problem, fix it and write a short note about what you changed. Auditors like to see that you catch your own errors.

Make a Simple Audit Folder

  • Last year's audit report and any notes from the auditor

  • Bank statements and monthly bank reconciliations

  • Signed grant agreements and donor letters

  • Payroll reports and tax filings

  • Board minutes that show the board approved the budget

Set up this folder at the start of the year, not the week the auditor arrives. Add to it each month. When the request list comes, you will already have most of what is needed.

Get Ready Before Audit Time

If you keep good records and split up your money duties, you are already ahead of most nonprofits. These two things are the reason most audits fail. Fix them, and you give your organization a real shot at passing with no surprises.


Get Your Free Audit Check Today

Do not wait until your auditor finds the gaps. Reach out to me today and I will do a free quick check of your books. You will walk away knowing exactly what to fix before your real audit happens.


Call or text me at 317-983-3980, or email me at markus@revampfinances.com.


Want Help With Your Books?

Get a free QuickBooks Health Checkup from Revamp Your Finances. I will look at your books and tell you what to fix.


Comments


bottom of page